DoZ Drama: Difference between revisions
(page created, summer 2009 stuff on Logicow lifted shamelessly or paraphrased from that page) |
(more doz drama, lifted/adapted from relevant articles) |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
''Day of Zeux Drama'' is the phenomenon by which [[MZXer|MegaZeuxers]] who participate in, judge or host a [[Day of Zeux]] competition create drama from disputes about rules, judging results. | ''Day of Zeux Drama'' is the phenomenon by which [[MZXer|MegaZeuxers]] who participate in, judge or host a [[Day of Zeux]] competition create drama from disputes about rules, judging results, or competition topics; mostly the second item. | ||
== Summer 2008 DsDoZ == | |||
There was a pair of snafus surrounding the [[Summer 2008 Dualstream Day of Zeux]] involving planning and information: the first was when [[Terryn]] put the dates of the MZXCon in the poll for wanted DoZ dates, and the second when [[asgromo]] thought the DoZ was going to start on a Friday instead of the voted Saturday. Another sticking point was the specific topic, which was "Summer 2008 DsDoZ and the End of the World." Nearly everyone considered it too specific and cumbersome. | |||
== Winter 2008 DsDoZ == | |||
In the [[Winter 2008 Dualstream Day of Zeux]], the judges were initially [[Tecki]], [[Aussie Evil]], [[SeventhShade]] and [[ScottVyper]], but after receiving fierce criticism over the quality of his scores Aussie Evil withdrew them and Terryn filled his place. ScottVyper's scores were also hotly contested and declaimed, prompting him to [[Leaving forever|leave forever]], but the scores themselves remained. | |||
== Summer 2009 DsDoZ == | == Summer 2009 DsDoZ == | ||
In the [[Summer 2009 Dualstream Day of Zeux]], [[LogiCow]] provided the obligatory DoZ drama, posting a lengthy complaint about the DoZ before the dust had even settled, and Leaving In A Huff. His game was the one disqualification in the competition, on counts of theme relevance, and of failing to run in MZX 2.82b (since he had produced it in the SVN development version). This resulted in LogiCow | In the [[Summer 2009 Dualstream Day of Zeux]], [[LogiCow]] provided the obligatory DoZ drama, posting a lengthy complaint about the DoZ before the dust had even settled, and Leaving In A Huff. His game was the one disqualification in the competition, on counts of theme relevance, and of failing to run in MZX 2.82b (since he had produced it in the SVN development version). This resulted in LogiCow leaving forever (but not really). Additionally, [[maxim]] felt that [[KKairos]] had exercised bad judgment in rating [[Goshi|Goshi's]] entry, [[Paranoid Heavens]], higher than his entry [[Achtung]]; KKairos agreed that this was probably incorrect. | ||
The debate preceding that same Day of Zeux, over the score-sheet changes in the main Day of Zeux thread of competitions (whether the theme-lite and theme-heavy scoresheets should be tied to the concrete and abstract topics, respectively) provided some amount of Day of Zeux drama. | The debate preceding that same Day of Zeux, over the score-sheet changes in the main Day of Zeux thread of competitions (whether the theme-lite and theme-heavy scoresheets should be tied to the concrete and abstract topics, respectively) provided some amount of Day of Zeux drama. | ||
== Winter 2010 DsDoZ == | |||
The [[Winter 2010 Dualstream Day of Zeux]] put previously established guidelines on judging quality and timeliness to the test when [[Kuddy]] submitted his scores at the end of the judging week without comments, and [[astral|astral's]] comments failed to meet the 300 word-per-game average. After strong complaints from [[Wervyn]], both scores were retracted. Despite the final scores being the result of only three combined judges, Wervyn insists that this is exactly what he had in mind when he proposed the system. | |||
== External Links == | == External Links == | ||
*[http://www.digitalmzx.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=14174 Winter 2008 DoZ Gradual Results Thread] | |||
*[http://www.digitalmzx.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=14190 Winter 2008 DoZ Final Results Thread] | |||
*[http://www.digitalmzx.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=14473 Logicow's complaints about the Summer 2009 DoZ] | *[http://www.digitalmzx.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=14473 Logicow's complaints about the Summer 2009 DoZ] | ||
*[http://www.digitalmzx.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=14382 The planning thread for the Summer 2009 DoZ] | *[http://www.digitalmzx.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=14382 The planning thread for the Summer 2009 DoZ] | ||
[[Category:Community]] [[Category:Competitions]] | [[Category:Community]] [[Category:Competitions]] |
Revision as of 05:57, 16 September 2010
Day of Zeux Drama is the phenomenon by which MegaZeuxers who participate in, judge or host a Day of Zeux competition create drama from disputes about rules, judging results, or competition topics; mostly the second item.
Summer 2008 DsDoZ
There was a pair of snafus surrounding the Summer 2008 Dualstream Day of Zeux involving planning and information: the first was when Terryn put the dates of the MZXCon in the poll for wanted DoZ dates, and the second when asgromo thought the DoZ was going to start on a Friday instead of the voted Saturday. Another sticking point was the specific topic, which was "Summer 2008 DsDoZ and the End of the World." Nearly everyone considered it too specific and cumbersome.
Winter 2008 DsDoZ
In the Winter 2008 Dualstream Day of Zeux, the judges were initially Tecki, Aussie Evil, SeventhShade and ScottVyper, but after receiving fierce criticism over the quality of his scores Aussie Evil withdrew them and Terryn filled his place. ScottVyper's scores were also hotly contested and declaimed, prompting him to leave forever, but the scores themselves remained.
Summer 2009 DsDoZ
In the Summer 2009 Dualstream Day of Zeux, LogiCow provided the obligatory DoZ drama, posting a lengthy complaint about the DoZ before the dust had even settled, and Leaving In A Huff. His game was the one disqualification in the competition, on counts of theme relevance, and of failing to run in MZX 2.82b (since he had produced it in the SVN development version). This resulted in LogiCow leaving forever (but not really). Additionally, maxim felt that KKairos had exercised bad judgment in rating Goshi's entry, Paranoid Heavens, higher than his entry Achtung; KKairos agreed that this was probably incorrect.
The debate preceding that same Day of Zeux, over the score-sheet changes in the main Day of Zeux thread of competitions (whether the theme-lite and theme-heavy scoresheets should be tied to the concrete and abstract topics, respectively) provided some amount of Day of Zeux drama.
Winter 2010 DsDoZ
The Winter 2010 Dualstream Day of Zeux put previously established guidelines on judging quality and timeliness to the test when Kuddy submitted his scores at the end of the judging week without comments, and astral's comments failed to meet the 300 word-per-game average. After strong complaints from Wervyn, both scores were retracted. Despite the final scores being the result of only three combined judges, Wervyn insists that this is exactly what he had in mind when he proposed the system.